Society of Trust and Estate Practitioners The Interface between Equitable Principles and Public Law

Fiduciary Obligations in Administrative Law

Download 173.08 Kb.
Size173.08 Kb.
1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   10   11
Fiduciary Obligations in Administrative Law
The private law of fiduciary obligations requires persons entrusted with powers for another's benefit to observe a general equitable obligation, when exercising such powers, to act honestly in what they consider to be the interests of the other. In this category we will find company directors, trustees, liquidators, executors, trustees in bankruptcy and others. The repositories of such powers are subjected, by reason of their equitable obligations, to judicial review of their actions. And as Paul Finn has said:

Perhaps not surprisingly, given the close resemblance which the fiduciary officer bears to the public official, this system of review reflects in a very large measure that described by the late Professor De Smith in Judicial Review of Administrative Action.76

A distinction has been drawn between the concept of a trust enforceable in equity and the public trust applicable to the discharge by public officers of duties or functions belonging to the prerogative and authority of the Crown.77 This has been said not to be a conventional but a 'higher' sense of the word.78 The distinction was relied upon by the Privy Council in 1902 in a case involving the allotment to a Maori Chief in 1870 of certain land over which native title had been extinguished. The land was to be held in trust by the Chief '… in the manner provided or hereafter to be provided by the General Assembly for native lands held under trust'. Notwithstanding the use of the term 'trust' it was held that the allottee had taken absolutely and beneficially and that there was no trust in favour of the traditional owners of the land.79

There is no presumption or general rule that the imposition or assumption of a statutory duty to perform certain functions gives rise to fiduciary obligations notwithstanding that the word 'trust' may be used.80 Nevertheless the existence of an unenforceable political trust is not inconsistent with the existence of particular duties imposed on public authorities which have a fiduciary character and are enforceable at law. The duty of local authorities in England has already been referred to as bearing similarities to that of the trustees or managers of the property of others.81 It was designated as 'fiduciary' in Bromley London Borough Council v Greater London Council.82 The analogy was supported in Gummow J's comparison between Wednesbury unreasonableness and abuse of fiduciary powers. The duty may operate as a mandatory relevant consideration which informs the exercise of discretionary powers involving expenditure or levying of charges and is an element to which the court will have regard in deciding whether a decision is unreasonable in the Wednesbury sense.83 It may simply be an analogy which helps to identify limits on power defined by the proper purposes of its exercise.

Whether or not the term fiduciary is properly applied to the relationship between the repositories of public power and those affected by its exercise, it is right to say that the classical fiduciary relationship between trustee and beneficiary '… is one particularly apt to illuminate the relationship between the government and the people'.84

Directory: assets -> publications -> speeches -> current-justices -> frenchcj
frenchcj -> Australian Bar Association Conference Why Rome and not Hong Kong — the Australian Bar at Large
frenchcj -> John Curtin Prime Ministerial Library 2013 Anniversary Lecture If they could see us now — what would the founders say?
frenchcj -> Inglis Clark — a living Force Andrew Inglis Clark and the Building of the Australian Nation Conference
frenchcj -> The Fine Art of Giving and Taking Offence Birkenhead Lecture
frenchcj -> The High Court, The Constitution and Australian Politics Book Launch
frenchcj -> Washington University in St Louis School of Law Liberty and Law in Australia
frenchcj -> The Courts and the Parliament
frenchcj -> Bending Words: The Fine Art of Interpretation University of Western Australia, Faculty of Law, Guest Lecture Series
frenchcj -> Australasian Law Teachers' Association Conference Legal Education in Australia – a never Ending Story Chief Justice Robert French ac
frenchcj -> The Tax Institute's 27th National Convention dg hill Memorial Lecture Tax and the Constitution

Share with your friends:

1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   10   11

The database is protected by copyright © 2020
send message

    Main page