Local Holism

Download 87.24 Kb.
Size87.24 Kb.
1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   10   11
Appendix 2:

A short summary of the different stances on communication and meaning

"The cat is on the mat"

* atomism:

cat and mat are concepts causally imposed in our mind.

The meaning of the sentence is given by the language of thought and corresponding causal relation with reality.

* strong molecularism

a speaker and a hearer have to know definitions of:

cat (x) -> animal (x) and feline (x) and makes "miau" (x)

mat (x) -> made of wool (x) and on the floor (x) and used for

* weak molecularism

a speaker and a hearer have to share, by chance:

some property of cat and mat, not necessarily the so called definitions; for instance: "cats like mice", and "mats are made of wool"

* global holism

a speaker and a hearer have to share the entire system of the meaning theory:

in the form: " 'the cat is on the mat' is true iff the cat is on the mat"

* convergence holism

a speaker and a hearer have to converge towards a common passing theory:

the hearer has to intend the intentions of the speaker, who - for instance - may intend with "cat" what hearer means with "dog" and with "mat" what the hearer means with "blanket". The corresponding inferences follow.

* local holism

"cat" and "mat" are words which take their meaning from the use of these words in a context with given axioms and rules of inferences. Unless you specify the cognitive context, the words have no meaning at all.

* weak local holism

"cat" and "mat" are word which are defined in typical definitory contexts, and their basic frame structure (a set of inferences) is lifted in any context, waiting for a verification of compatibility. Changes are made afterwards.

Share with your friends:
1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   10   11

The database is protected by copyright ©essaydocs.org 2020
send message

    Main page