International Law Outline



Download 320.5 Kb.
Page48/128
Date20.01.2021
Size320.5 Kb.
1   ...   44   45   46   47   48   49   50   51   ...   128
Sosa v. Alvarez-Machain – 2004 (333-38)

  1. Mexican national accomplice to murder of undercover DEA agent. DEA approves abduction of A-M to US to stand trial.

    1. US rejects argument that kidnapping divests US of jurisdiction.

    2. A-M acquitted.

  2. A-M files suit to recover damages from abductors under ATS.

  3. SOUTER Majority

    1. ATS creates SOME causes of action. Just not this one.

    2. Defining “law of nations” in 1789

      1. Allows re: violation of safe conduct, infringement of ambassador rights, piracy

    3. Argues we can’t freeze it at those three – but judicial RESTRAINT in allowing new ones. Why restraint?

      1. Common law has changed since 1789. Doesn’t exist in vacuum, as we used to think. Now recognize that new right of action is being CREATED.

      2. Rethinking of role of federal courts re: fed common law. ERIE.

      3. Creating private right of action is better left to legislature in vast majority of cases.

      4. Judiciary should be restrained because it has potential implications re: foreign relations, where legislative and exec branch have great discretion

        1. Worry about suits that tell other countries how to treat their citizens

      5. No congressional mandate to define new violations of law of nations

        1. Did get one with TVAP – but well-defined

    4. Quarter century since Filartiga – no legislation forbidding, or saying courts shouldn’t do this.

    5. A-M gets nothing – no case here.

      1. Reject argument that there is customary law prohibiting arbitrary arrest

        1. His argument is too broad – saying any time officially sanctioned action exceeds its positive authorization to detain under its own law

      2. Single day of illegal detention followed by transfer of custody to lawful authorities and prompt arraignment – violates no norm of customary international law.

      3. PA – could have looked at ICCPR – norm against arbitrary detention (thought we haven’t signed), UN working group on arbitrary detention, ICTY jurisprudence)

  4. SCALIA Concurrence in Part and in Judgment – not a question of what congressional act would PREVENT courts from applying “law of nations”, but what act AUTHORIZES exception from Erie holding that general federal common law does not exist.

  • Ferdinand Marcos – Philippine Torture Victims

    1. Relevance – governments (states, and their instrumentalities) have immunities in courts

      1. Can’t sue state – except under Sovereign Immunities Act

      2. Thus, have to explore other routes.

    2. Marcos declares martial law, and harshly represses all political dissent – including use of torture. Also engaged in widespread, systematic theft. Deposed, and flew to HI.

      1. Several lawsuits filed in US courts for HR violations.

        1. 30 for named individuals.

          1. Some got default judgments

        2. Several class action suits.

          1. Some got exemplary damages.

        3. Philippines itself filed action in CA state & federal court, and NY, NJ, TX federal courts to recover $ Marcos stole from treasury

  • Other ATS Cases


    1. Directory: sites -> default -> files -> upload documents
      upload documents -> Always put things in threes (eskridge has ocd) I. Procedural Due Process and Reading a Case
      upload documents -> Federalism – The Structure of Government
      upload documents -> General Info About Property law
      upload documents -> Con law professor Larry Sager Fall 1995 I. U. S. Term limits V. Thornton
      upload documents -> Property with Professor Vicki Been
      upload documents -> Property Outline – Professor Upham, Spring 2000
      upload documents -> Constitutional law outline part I: structure of government judicial review and constitutional interpretation
      upload documents -> Complex federal investigations
      upload documents -> Foundations: Agency Law Introduction to law of enterprise organizations
      upload documents -> Pricing v. Sanctions


      Share with your friends:
  • 1   ...   44   45   46   47   48   49   50   51   ...   128




    The database is protected by copyright ©essaydocs.org 2020
    send message

        Main page