Frank stuart dethridge memorial address the far from halcyon isle



Download 222.56 Kb.
Page16/16
Date04.04.2021
Size222.56 Kb.
1   ...   8   9   10   11   12   13   14   15   16
South Africa: Southern Steamship Agency Inc v MV “Khalij Sky” 1986 (1) SAf LR 485

53 1989 (4) SA 325

54 Andrico Unity 1989 (4) SA at 330D, 332B-D

55 ALRC 33 at p 91 [123]

56 ALRC 33 at p 92 [123]

57 [1981] AC 221

58 157 FCR at 78 [114]-[115]

59 see DR Thomas, Maritime Liens (1980) Stevens & Sons Ltd: London, at [371]-[374]

60 at [575]-[579]

61 [1946] P at 145

62 [1978] 1 MLJ 189

63 or at least that of Bankes LJ

64 [1923] P 102 at 106ff; Thomas, Maritime Liens at [579], [585]

65 (2005: 4th ed) informa: London, at [17.57]-[17.58]

66 [1981] AC 221

67 Jackson op cit at [26.17]

68 [1981] AC 221

69 Jackson op cit at [26.41

70 Jackson op cit at [26.43], [26.178]

71 (2008:14th ed) Oxford University Press at 92-94

72 [1923] P 102

73 (2007) Oxford University Press at [4.50]-[4.51]

74 [1981] AC 221

75 Eds. Prof CGJ Morse, D McClean & Lord Collins of Mapesbury (2012: 15th ed) Sweet & Maxwell; Thomson Reuters at [7-018], [70041]

76 [1981] AC at 235C-D

77 at [7-041]

78 See his essay, “Maritime Liens in Conflict of Laws”, published in JAR Nafziger & Symeon C Symeonides eds, Law and Justice in a Multi-State World: Essays in Honour of Arthur T von Mehren (2002) Transnational Publishers Inc: Ardsley NY, 439 at 448

79 See the highly debatable case comment supporting the majority decision, by M.M. Cohen, “In defense of the Halcyon Isle” [1987] LMCLQ 152 at pp. 154-155. See also in reply Tetley, “In Defence of the Ioannis Daskalelis” [1989] LMCLQ 11

80 For a comprehensive critique of the majority decision in The Halcyon Isle, see generally Tetley, International Conflict of Laws, Common, Civil and Maritime (1994) International Shipping Publications, at pp 570-573

81 (2010: 8th ed) LexisNexis, Australia at [16.43]

82 [1997] FCA 432; 1998 AMC 1727 at 1733

83 [1981] AC 221

84 (2000) 203 CLR 503: see too Davies and Lewins, “Foreign Maritime Liens: Should they be recognised in Australian Courts?” (2002) 76 ALJ 775

85 [1981] AC 221

86 [1987] LMCLQ 152

87 [1987] LMCLQ at 154

88 [1981] AC 221

89 1986 (1) SA 485 at 490-493

90 [1923] P 102; 1986 (1) SA at 493E-H; a view shared in an obiter dictum by Nienaber J in Oriental Commercial and Shipping Co Ltd v MV Fidias 1986 (1) SA 714 at 719C-D

91 [1981] AC 221

92 1989 (4) SA 325

93 1989 (4) SA at 340C-E

94 [1981] AC 221

95 1989 (4) SA at 347D-E

96 1989 (4) SA at 344E-F, 346H-J, 348E-349F

97 cf: 1989 (4) SA 5 at 347A-J

98 (1870) LR 6 QB 1

99 (2002) 210 CLR 491

100 210 CLR at 515-517 [61]-[67] per Gleeson CJ, Gaudron, McHugh, Gummow and Hayne JJ

101 [1981] AC 221

102 [1999] 3 NZLR 111 at 115 (Fisher J)

103 [1992] 1 NZLR 655 (Cooke P, McKay and McGechnan JJ)

104 [1993] 3 NZLR 576 (Holland J)

105 [1997] FCA 432, 1998 AMC 1727

106 [1981] AC 221

107 (1984) 4 DLR (4th) 739

108 see [1997] FCA 432 at p 37, 1998 AMC at 1732. Sheppard J also noted that the decision in The “Betty Ott” [1992] 1 NZLR 655 was not entirely in accord with the majority.

109 210 CLR at 522 [86]

110 Prosser, “Interstate Publication” (1953) 51 Michigan Law Review 959 at p 971

111 Cheshire, Private International Law (1953) p vii in North, “Private International Law: Change or Decay?” (2001) 50 International and Comparative Law Quarterly 477

112 Cardozo, The Paradoxes of Legal Science (1928) p 67

113 [1981] AC at 230E-F

114 [1981] AC 221

115 [1997] FCA 432; 1998 AMC 1727

116 203 CLR at 543-544 [99]-[100]

117 (1991) 174 CLR 1 at 26-27

118 Stevens v Head (1993) 176 CLR 433 at 445 per Mason CJ

119 Pfeiffer 203 CLR at 543 [99]

120 (2005) 223 CLR 331 per Gleeson CJ, Gummow, Kirby, Hayne, Callinan and Heydon JJ, with McHugh J dissenting

121 210 CLR 491

122 223 CLR 331

123 223 CLR at 366 [98]-[99]

124 Pfeiffer (2000) 203 CLR 503 at 542-543 [97] per Gleeson CJ, Gaudron, McHugh, Gummow and Hayne JJ

125 Khan-Freund p 290

126 223 CLR at 342 [13], 344 [17] per Gleeson CJ; 374 [134] per Gummow and Hayne JJ; 412-413 [250]-[256] per Callinan J; 416-417 [267]-[268], 418-419 [271], 420 [277] per Heydon J; and see too Kirby J, in dissent but agreeing on this point at 388 [175]

127 223 CLR at 342 [13]

128 223 CLR at 362-367 [84]-[100]

129 223 CLR at 363 [87]

130 223 CLR at 363 [89]

131 223 CLR at 364 [92], [94]

132 223 CLR at 365 [96]

133 Vita Food Products Inc v Unus Shipping Co [1939] AC 277 at 290-292; cp Neilson 223 CLR at 357 [65]

134 Toll (FGCT) Pty Ltd v Alphapharm Pty Ltd (2004) 219 CLR 165 at 174-176 [33]-[40]

135 [1937] AC 500 at 529-531: see too at 567 per Lord Maugham, 573 per Lord Roche and 575 per Lord Macmillan agreeing; Akai 188 CLR at 441; Vita Food [1939] AC at 290

136 Neilson 223 CLR at 365 [96], 366 [99], per Gummow and Hayne JJ

137 (1950) 81 CLR 486 [1951] AC 201 at 219

138 (2010: 8th ed) LexisNexis Australia

139 (2012) Oxford University Press at 53-57 [3.09]-[3.14]

140 223 CLR 331

141 223 CLR at 363 [87]

142 [1939] AC at 292

143 particularly at [1939] AC at 290-292

144 [1939] AC at 290

145 [1937] AC 500 at 529

146 (1971) 124 CLR 245 at 252 and 260

147 [1939] AC at 290

148 [1984] AC 50 at 61D-62C

149 as it also is in its Australian analogue

150 [1984] AC at 61H-62A

151 [1984] AC at 69G-70A

152 In re United Railways of the Havana and Regla Warehouses Ltd [1960] Ch 52 at 96-97 per Jenkins and Romer LJJ and at 115 per Willmer LJ

153 7th ed at 72, 73, 721 and 722

154 “The Proper Law of a Contract in the Conflict of Laws” (1940) 56 LQR 320 at 333-335

155 [1939] AC 277 at 292

156 (2012: 15th ed) Sweet & Maxwell, London at xxiv

157 [1939] AC at 291

158 56 LQR at 333

159 56 LQR at 335

160 15th ed at 1793 [32-029]

161 223 CLR at 368 [109]

162 [1984] AC at 61D-62C

163 [2005] EWHC 1323 Ch at [108]-[110]

164 [1995] 1 WLR 978 at 1008D and G

165 [1995] 1 WLR at 1008D

166 J Fawcett and J Curruthers (2008: 14th ed) Oxford University Press at 71

167 (1998) 47 International and Comparative Law Quarterly 877 at 881

168 see 47 ICLQ at 880-881: see too the Contracts (Applicable Law) Act 1990 (UK), referred to in Cheshire, North and Fawcett (2008) op cit at 71

169 [2006] WASCA 25

170 223 CLR 331

171 at [60], Malcolm CJ agreeing at [1]; and McLure JA at [18]

172 Pfeiffer 203 CLR at 543-544 [99]-[100]; Neilson 223 CLR 331

173 203 CLR at 543-544 [99]-[100]

174 [1981] AC 221




Share with your friends:
1   ...   8   9   10   11   12   13   14   15   16




The database is protected by copyright ©essaydocs.org 2020
send message

    Main page