Definitions, Explanations and Quotes. Part 1: Crime What is a Crime? The best definition of crime is that given by Coleman and Cressey: "Crime is a violation of the criminal law. No matter how indecent or immoral an act may be, it is not a crime unless the criminal law has listed it as a crime and provided a punishment for it." The point made here is that a crime is an act defined by law (and not necessarily by
morality). If my family is starving and I steal a loaf of bread to feed them, I may have committed an act that you deem to be morally justified (or, at least, not immoral) but I have broken the law, the criminal law of Singapore. However, if a man leaves his wife and four children and runs off with his neighbour's wife, you would consider this to be a highly immoral act, but he has not broken the law. Neither adultery nor abandoning your family are criminal acts.
the punishment is meted to someone for breaching established standards of social behaviour
Purposes/Aims of Punishment Draw a “mind map” of the different types of punishment you can think of below:
There are five possible purposes to the punishment of criminals: 1. Incapacitation: A felon in prison cannot commit crimes while imprisoned. An executed felon cannot commit a crime ever again.
2. Deterrence: The threat of punishment deters people from engaging in illegal acts.
3. Restitution: The felon is required to take some action to at least partially return the victim to the status quo ante.
4. Retribution: The felon harmed society; therefore society (or the direct victims) is entitled to inflict harm in return.
5. Rehabilitation: The punishment changes the felon in order to make him a better citizen afterwards. (The punishment can include mandatory vocational training, counseling, drug treatment, etc.)
In order for a punishment to be justified, it must satisfy at least one of these criteria. (There may be reasons to oppose a punishment even if it does satisfy these criteria, so this is a necessary, but not a sufficient, condition.) Theories of Punishment: The above-mentioned can be sorted and re-categorized into two competing theories of punishment: the Utilitarian Theory and the Retributive Theory:
1. Utilitarian Theory – Focuses on achieving social benefit:
a. Deterrence – In general, it has been found that an increase in the detection, arrest and conviction rate is a greater deterrence to crime than an increase in the punishment.
b. Incapacitation – Removing dangerous individuals from society protects society from that person.
c. Rehabilitation – Offenders can be “changed” into productive members of society if given proper treatment.
• NOTE: This may be a goal of punishment, but it is not a justification for punishment and in today’s system, it has been all but rejected.
2. Retributive Theory – Society is under a moral obligation to punish a defendant who deserves punishment. It is wrong to punish the innocent and we must take steps to avoid doing so, but a guilty person must be punished.
a. Assaultive – Punishment is justified by the crime. It is not necessary to look at the rights of the guilty or consider his or her “best interests.”
b. Protective – The guilty has benefited from the crime and society has paid the price. Thus, the guilty person owes a debt to society.
Are There Any Benefits to Punishment? 1. Acts as a Form of Protection to Society
Punishment which takes the form of imprisonment protects society from such criminals as such punishment incapacitates the criminal such that he cannot commit the offence again.
2. Acts as a Form of General Deterrence
Punishment acts as a form of deterrent. Knowing the punishment that follows crime and seeing others punished will deter the general public from criminal acts even if they know that they may not be caught.
3. Acts as a Form Individual Deterrence
Punishment also deters the criminal himself from committing further crime as he has already borne the consequences of his criminal actions and he fears that if he repeats his act, he will be similarly punished again.
4. Reinforces Social Norms
Punishment plays a significant role maintaining social norms as it serves to reinforce how certain acts which transgress or violate accepted standards of behaviour is wrong and will be condemned.
5. Acts as a Means of Reforming Criminals
If punishment .takes the form of rehabilitation eg. counseling or detention at reformation centres, then this helps to reform criminals. This view is based on the assumption that psychological therapy can alter the basic characteristics of the offender such that he becomes repentant. Reforming offenders may also take the form of providing appropriate training programmes for them to facilitate the individual's re-entry into society.
6. Acts as a Form of Vengeance
When a criminal is punished, the families of the victims feel that justice is served and this helps develops the victim's and their families' respect for the law. Punishment sanctioned by the state also cuts down the need for private vengeance when the victim may take matters in his own hands.
Quotes "I never wonder to see men wicked but I often wonder to see them not ashamed."
Jonathan Swift "In my judgement, one of the basic reasons we have had crime, lawlessness and disorder in the United States has been the breakdown of the family unit."
Robert F. Kennedy "Justice discards party, .friendship and kindred, and is therefore represented as blind."
Joseph Addison "It is better that ten guilty persons escape than one innocent suffer" (i.e. that one innocent person be found guilty of a crime that he or she did not commit)
Sir William Blackstone "The love of justice in most men is only the fear of themselves suffering injustice."
Duc Francois de la Rochefoucauld "Jails and prisons are the complement of schools; so the less you have of the latter, the more you have of the former.”
Horace Mann "Ignorant people believe that if punishment is not severe enough crimes will increase. As a metter of fact, the reverse is true.
Jawaharlal Nehru "I shall ask for the abolition of the punishment of death until I have the infallibility of human judgement demonstrated to me."
Thomas Jefferson "Crime is a violation of the criminal law. No matter how indecent or immoral an act may be, it is not a crime unless the criminal law has listed it as a crime and provided a punishment for it."