Cmsdl core Files



Download 1.28 Mb.
Page1/48
Date25.04.2016
Size1.28 Mb.
#19536
  1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   ...   48

CMSDL Core Files 2015-2016

2015-2016


CMSDL Core Files
Researched by Hanna Nasser, Alix Dahl, David Song and Mike Baxter-Kauf (with contributions from Cydney Edwards, Roman Motley, and Travis Ormsby)

Resolved: The United States federal government should substantially curtail its domestic surveillance



Core Files Table of Contents 1/4

*** Stingray Affirmative 3

Stingray Affirmative Summary 4

2AC Extensions – Solvency (Banning StingRay Solves) 25

2AC Answers to Crime Disadvantage 30

*** Stingray Negative 31

1NC Answers to: Solvency 37

2NC/1NR Extensions (Harms – Racial Profiling) – Racial Profiling is Inevitable 38

2NC/1NR Extensions to Harms (Democracy) – Stingray Abuses Under Check Now 40



*** National Security Letters Affirmative 46

National Security Letters Summary 47

National Security Letters 1AC –Plan 48

National Security Letters 1AC – Harms (Privacy) 49

National Security Letters 1AC – Harms (Privacy) 50

National Security Letters 1AC – Harms (Racism) 51

National Security Letters 1AC – Harms (Racism) 52

National Security Letters 1AC – Solvency 53

Answers to: Terrorism Disadvantage 54

Answers to: Terrorism Disadvantage 56

Answers to: Crime Disadvantage 57

2AC Extensions: Privacy 58

2AC Extensions: Racism 60

2AC Extensions – Solvency 62

*** National Security Letters Negative 63

1NC Solvency 64

1NC Racism Harms 65

1NC Privacy Harms 66

1NC Privacy Harms 67

*** Drone Affirmative 68

1AC 69

Drones 1AC - Plan 70



2AC Harms Frontlines 76

2AC Civil Liberties Extensions 77

2AC Civil Liberties Extensions - ANSWERS TO: Obama Regulating Drones Now 78

2AC Civil Liberties Extensions - Impact 79

2AC Innovation 80

2AC Solvency 81

ANSWERS TO: Elections Disadvantage (Drones Affirmative) 82



*** Drone Negative 84

1NC Advantage Frontlines 85

1NC Civil Liberties FRONTLINE 86

1NC Innovation FRONTLINE 87

1NC Solvency FRONTLINE 88



2NC/1NR Advantage Frontline Extensions 89

2NC/1NR Civil Liberties 90

2NC/1NR Innovation 91

2NC/1NR Solvency 92



Advantage Frontline Extensions 93

ANSWERS TO: Inherency- Extensions 94

ANSWERS TO: Civil Liberties- Impact Framing 95

2NC/1NR ANSWERS TO: Solvency- Extensions 96



***Topicality Negative 97

1NC Violations 98

**Federal Government 99

1NC Drone Surveillance- “Federal Government” Violation 100

1NC Stingray- “Federal Government” Violation 102

**Curtail ≠ Abolish 104

1NC Security Letters- Curtail ≠ Abolish 105

2NC/1NR Topicality Blocks 106

2NC/1NR- ANSWERS TO: Reasonability 107



***”Federal Government” Violation 108

2NC/1NR - “Federal Government”- Extensions 109

2NC/1NR - “Its”- Extensions 110

**2NC/1NR Drone Affirmative 111

2NC/1NR Drone Affirmative- “Federal Government”- Overview 112

2NC/1NR Drone Affirmative- “Federal Government”- Violation 113

**2NC/1NR Stingray Affirmative 114

2NC/1NR Drone Affirmative- “Federal Government”- Overview 115

2NC/1NR Stingray Affirmative- “Federal Government”- Violation 116

***Curtail ≠ Abolish 117

**2NC/1NR National Security Letters Affirmative 118

2NC/1NR Security Letters- Curtail ≠ Abolish – Overview 119

2NC/1NR Security Letters- Curtail ≠ Abolish – Interpretation Extensions 120

**Topicality Affirmative 121

**2AC Blocks 122

2AC- Drone Affirmative- T “Federal Government” 123

2AC- Stingray Affirmative- T “Federal Government” 124

2AC Security Letters 125

Crime Disadvantage 126

Crime DA 1NC 127

Crime DA 1NC 128

Crime DA 1NC 129

Crime DA 1NC 130

2NC/1NR Link Extensions: General 132

2NC/1NR Extensions: National Security Letters Link 133

2NC/1NR Link Extensions - Drone Surveillance 135

2NC/1NR Uniqueness Extensions – Crime Low Now 137

2NC/1NR Impacts Turns Case - Surveillance 138

2NC/1NR Impacts Turns Case – Racism 139

2NC/1NR Impacts – Economy 140

2NC/1NR Impact – Poverty/Structural Violence 142



Crime Disadvantage Affirmative Answers 143

Non-unique: Crime High Now 144

No Link - Surveillance doesn’t reduce crime 145

Answers to: Crime Hurts Economy 147



Terrorism Disadvantage 148

2NC/1NR Extensions: National Security Letters Link 153

2NC/1NR Extension: Impact (Nuclear Terrorism) 162

Terrorism DA Affirmative Answers 173

**Elections Disadvantage Negative 184

1NC Hillary Good 185

**Uniqueness- Hillary Good 188

Uniqueness- Hillary Good- ANSWERS TO: Bernie Sanders 189



2NC/1NR- Uniqueness Wall- Hillary Good 191

**Links- Hillary good 194

Link Wall- Drone Affirmative 195

Link Wall- Stingray Affirmative 199

Link Wall- Security Letters Affirmative 200

2NC/1NR Answers to: No Link – Surveillance Policy Not Key to Election 202

2NC/1NR Answer to: No Link – Election Too Far Off 204

2NC/1NR Answer to: Impact Turn – Iran Deal 206



**Elections Disadvantage Affirmative 211

**2AC Blocks 212

2AC Hillary Good- Link Turn Strategy 213

2AC Hillary Good – Impact Turn Strategy 217

**A2- Hillary Good- 1AR Extensions 220

1AR Hillary Good – Non-Unique: Hillary Loses Now (Bernie Sanders) 221

1AR Hillary Good – Non-Unique: Hillary Loses Now (General Election) 223

Washington Examiner, 2015 223

1AR Hillary Good – No Link – Surveillance doesn’t swing votes 225

1AR Hillary Good – Link Turn – Surveillance reform is popular 226

1AR Hillary Good – Impact Turn – Iran Deal Bad 228

**States COUNTERPLAN Negative 230

1NC States Counterplan 231

2NC/1NR- States COUNTERPLAN- Solvency- Overview 232

2NC/1NR- States COUNTERPLAN- Solvency- Drone Aff 233

2NC/1NR- States COUNTERPLAN- Solvency- Security Letters 234

2NC/1NR- States COUNTERPLAN- Solvency- Stingray Affirmative 235

2NC/1NR- States COUNTERPLAN- ANSWERS TO: Permutation 237

2NC/1NR- States COUNTERPLAN- ANSWERS TO: Fifty State Fiat Bad 238

**States COUNTERPLAN Affirmative 239

2AC- States Counterplan 240

2AC- States COUNTERPLAN- Solvency Deficit- Drone Affirmative 242

2AC- States COUNTERPLAN- Solvency Deficit- Security Letters Affirmative 243

2AC- States COUNTERPLAN- Solvency Deficit- Stingray Affirmative 244



**CISA DISADVANTAGE Negative 245

1NC- CISA DISADVANTAGE 246

**Uniqueness 249

2NC/1NR- CISA DISADVANTAGE- Uniqueness Wall 250



**Link 251

2NC/1NR – CISA DISADVANTAGE- Link Wall- Drone Affirmative 252

2NC/1NR- CISA DISADVANTAGE- Link Wall- Stingray Affirmative 254

2NC/1NR- CISA DISADVANTAGE- Link Wall- Security Letters 255



**Impact 257

2NC/1NR- CISA DISADVANTAGE- ANSWERS TO: CISA Good 258



**CISA DISADVANTAGE Affirmative 260

2AC- CISA DISADVANTAGE- Link Turn Strategy 261

2AC- CISA DISADVANTAGE- Impact Turn Strategy 263

2AC- CISA DISADVANTAGE- Drone Affirmative- No Link/Link Turn 265






Download 1.28 Mb.

Share with your friends:
  1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   ...   48




The database is protected by copyright ©essaydocs.org 2022
send message

    Main page