Case extension


at: Framework – at: ground (0:20)



Download 80.83 Kb.
Page5/10
Date07.04.2021
Size80.83 Kb.
1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   10

at: Framework – at: ground (0:20)


plan text checks ground – we defend topical federal government action in our story – meets every textual burden – any other violation is an arbitrary, self-serving spec requirement – most affs presume literalism, we explicitly defend our position – increases negative ground and prevents 2AC sand-bagging
b. bidirectional rez checks – built-in energy trade-offs means they should be packing a response to our plan like oil good etc.

at: topic education/policy relevance (0:40/??)


This is a terrible standard – presumes a one to one link between plan text we advocate in round and what occurs in the policy process – voting for SMRs doesn’t mean you get a world of SMRs in 20 years – we’re the only ones impacting what the act of VOTING means for politics


at: Framework – at: extra T (0:15)


No extra-T – all affs take a stance on the debate space – we just do it out loud – guarantees more negative ground and prevents 2AC sand-bagging or shifting
Self-reflexivity outweighs – questioning why we’re here and what we’re doing is key to meaning – debate without a context is just coin flipping and repetition


Directory: download -> Georgetown
Georgetown -> The affirmative re-inscribes the primacy of liberal legalism as a method of restraint—that paradoxically collapses resistance to Executive excesses
Georgetown -> The United States Supreme Courts should restrict the President’s war powers authority to indefinitely detain, on the grounds that the Geneva Conventions confer a private right of action
Georgetown -> The gross misperception of risk that informs so much anti-nuclear fear
Georgetown -> Immigration reform is up—Obama has leverage—that’s key to overcome gop obstructionism Jeff Mason
Georgetown -> The aff’s call to fix a world gone astray is part of debate’s fixation on the suffering of the Other – this perspective is one of prescriptive colonialism that leads to endless violence
Georgetown -> Immigration reform is up—Obama has leverage—that’s key to overcome gop obstructionism
Georgetown -> Catastrophic anthropogenic warming is happening – observable data and a scientific consensus
Georgetown -> Escalating public and international backlash against future drone use will crush effectiveness – the plan is key to reverse that sentiment
Georgetown -> Escalating public and international backlash against future drone use will crush effectiveness – the plan is key to reverse that sentiment
Georgetown -> The plan is key to prevent an escalating public backlash against future drone use Zenko 13


Share with your friends:
1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   10




The database is protected by copyright ©essaydocs.org 2020
send message

    Main page