Case extension


at: Framework – CI + Offense (0:50)



Download 80.83 Kb.
Page2/10
Date07.04.2021
Size80.83 Kb.
1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   10

at: Framework – CI + Offense (0:50)


Counter-interpretation: the resolution is a story – the 1AC is a topical future history – our meta-framing subsumes but doesn’t contradict their definitions
Resolved is to reduce by mental analysis,

Random House 11 (http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/resolve)
Our engagement is good:

a. Science fiction stories are necessary to respond to denialism – passive scientism refuses to fully recognize and act on the consequences of climate – we must incorporate new ways of knowing or risk extinction– that’s Oreskes and Darder – tying it to politics is the critical for effective political action – that’s McCalmont – we just change consciousness before policy
b. Politics is already ceded – the carbon combustion complex has it on lock – we need to start with new pedagogies and understandings of climate to have meaningful reform – we do not deny state action but foreground our relation to it
c. Performativity is key – debate is meaningful because of its liberatory and disruptive potential – reducing it to questions of policy engineering misses it’s broader effect – that’s Kulynych – questioning of the tone of the resolution inverts the traditional understanding of federal energy policy enthralling the public
The aff outweighs – climate based destruction and the anti-ecological pedagogies exist now – preserving debate as an intellectual pastime is useless unless it can oppose denialism


Directory: download -> Georgetown
Georgetown -> The affirmative re-inscribes the primacy of liberal legalism as a method of restraint—that paradoxically collapses resistance to Executive excesses
Georgetown -> The United States Supreme Courts should restrict the President’s war powers authority to indefinitely detain, on the grounds that the Geneva Conventions confer a private right of action
Georgetown -> The gross misperception of risk that informs so much anti-nuclear fear
Georgetown -> Immigration reform is up—Obama has leverage—that’s key to overcome gop obstructionism Jeff Mason
Georgetown -> The aff’s call to fix a world gone astray is part of debate’s fixation on the suffering of the Other – this perspective is one of prescriptive colonialism that leads to endless violence
Georgetown -> Immigration reform is up—Obama has leverage—that’s key to overcome gop obstructionism
Georgetown -> Catastrophic anthropogenic warming is happening – observable data and a scientific consensus
Georgetown -> Escalating public and international backlash against future drone use will crush effectiveness – the plan is key to reverse that sentiment
Georgetown -> Escalating public and international backlash against future drone use will crush effectiveness – the plan is key to reverse that sentiment
Georgetown -> The plan is key to prevent an escalating public backlash against future drone use Zenko 13


Share with your friends:
1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   10




The database is protected by copyright ©essaydocs.org 2020
send message

    Main page