Are universal human rights a form of cultural imperialism?



Download 190.84 Kb.
Page10/10
Date31.05.2016
Size190.84 Kb.
1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   10

6. Concluding Discussion


We set out to determine the extent to which human rights, and especially gay rights, can be perceived as a form of Western cultural imperialism, in the light of recent debates over the rights of homosexuals in several African countries. Our point of departure was the debate between advocates of universal human rights law and cultural relativists; a debate surrounding the question whether it is possible and expedient to formulate a set of universally binding human rights or if such would neglect to consider global cultural diversity.

Human rights have in general become an incorporated part in most countries, as the respect and promotion of such is increasingly seen as a precondition for a state to be perceived as legitimate. The rights of sexual minorities have in general been assigned a lower priority or to a great extent ignored. Recently, however, gay rights have become a more frequently debated subject internationally, as stricter laws criminalizing homosexual practices have been implemented in several countries, especially within the African continent.



We built our analysis on the theoretical framework surrounding international human rights law, cultural relativism, cultural imperialism, and homosexuality. Our object of analysis was mainly the ACHPR, supplemented by the UDHR and ECHR. Based on the rhetoric of these covenants, we set out to examine the grounds for rights concerning sexual orientation, somewhat expecting the Western originating covenants to be more explicit in their inclusion of sexual orientation as a human right. However, this was not confirmed by simply reading the documents, as none of them mention sexual orientation directly. Nevertheless, they can all be interpreted to apply to homosexuals. The UDHR states that everyone is entitled to the rights expressed within the charter “without distinction of any kind, such as race, colour, sex, language, religion, political or other opinion, national or social origin, property, birth or other status” (Article 2 UDHR, 1948). Both the ECHR and ACHPR contain almost identical formulations to that of UDHR in their articles concerning the entitlement of rights (ECHR Article 14 and ACHPR Article 2). As stated in the analysis, supporting grounds for the inclusion of sexual orientation can be found in the term ‘sex’ and especially also in the term ‘other status’. This notion has been supported by the ECtHR, who established that sexual orientation is included in ‘other status’ under its Article 14.

In general, all three covenants are remarkably similar in content and formulation. However, we found differences in the usage and implementation of the different documents, which was specified in the examples included in our analysis section. For example, we found that the ECtHR is more likely to interpret the ECHR to benefit sexual minorities in specific cases involving discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation. Whereas the ACtHPR is more likely to interpret the ACHPR as to exclude sexual minorities from enjoying these rights as such practices are perceived as ‘unAfrican’. The fact that the ACHPR is somewhat inspired by Western charters on human rights, such as the ECHR and the American Convention on Human Rights, supports the notion of Western influence. It therefore, to some extent, also supports the notion of cultural imperialism as it builds on Western originated formulations of human rights. On the other hand, the fact that the charters are alike could also imply support for universal human rights, as it might simply serve as an implication that these regions all perceive the same rights as essential. Nevertheless, gay rights as a human right is a rather controversial matter which, so far, has a higher probability of being supported in the West.

South Africa remains an exception to this, due to its political reform in the 1990s. It is hence essential to emphasize the size and disparity of the African continent when making conclusions on this matter, as situations differ vastly throughout the continent. Still, many African countries face the same social, economic, and political issues and share somewhat similar histories, and a general notion of African unity prevails. Therefore, we have maintained a more general perspective throughout this project.

Previously, the conditions for sexual minorities were unfavorable in Europe as well and including sexual orientation in the context of non-discrimination is a relatively new tendency. Based on the process concerning rights of LGBT people as seen in Europe, it could be anticipated that a similar development might take place in the African region. This assumption is supported by the fact that current conditions for sexual minorities in Africa somewhat resemble the previous situation in Europe. Also, the ACHPR was not adopted until 1981 - more than 30 years after both the UDHR and the ECHR. Thus, in the context of human rights, the African countries might simply be further behind in the process and might take on such changes when demanded by its citizens.

In sum, human rights and especially gay rights can, to some extent, be seen as a form of Western cultural imperialism in the sense that the notion of universal human rights fails to consider differing cultural values; a view in overall accordance with the perspective of cultural relativists. Furthermore, Western notions of human rights are, to some extent, attempted coercively implemented, for example by withdrawing or redirecting economic support in African countries where these rights are not upheld. On the contrary, human rights are not simply a Western tendency and approaches to protect people and their rights have been implemented worldwide. The ACHPR is, for example, unique in its focus on collective rights and inclusion of traditional African values, further supporting that human rights are not simply Western. Nonetheless, the principle of universally binding human rights is, to some extent, dominated by Western values and can therefore be perceived as a form of cultural imperialism.

7. List of References


ACHPR - The African (Banjul) Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights (1981) Organization of African Unity. Adopted 27 June 1981. Entered into force 21 October 1986. (pp. 1-18).

ACmHPR - The African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights (2010) 28th Activity Report of the ACHPR (pp. 1-153). Retrieved from http://www.achpr.org/files/activity-reports/28/achpr47eo8_actrep28_20092010_eng.pdf

Adjovi, R. (2012 November 5) 5: Understanding the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights. Think Africa Press. Retrieved from http://thinkafricapress.com/international-law-africa/african-charter-human-peoples-rights

African Commission on Human and Peoples' Rights (2001, 23 April-7th May). Legal Resources Foundation v. Zambia, Communication No. 211/98.

Aljazeera (2014 February). Ugandan President sign anti-gay law. Aljazeera. Retrieved from http://www.aljazeera.com/news/africa/2014/02/ugandan-president-sign-anti-gay-bill-20142245119120579.html

Amnesty International (2014). Rising Levels of Homophobia in sub-Saharan Africa are Dangerous and Must be Tackled. Retrieved from http://www.amnesty.org/en/news/rising-levels-homophobia-sub-saharan-africa-are-dangerous-and-must-be-tackled-2013-06-24

Armer, J. M. & Katsillis, J. (2000): Modernization Theory. In E.F. Borgatta & R.J.V. Montgomery (Eds). Encyclopedia of Sociology (second ed.) USA: Macmillan.

AU - The African Union (2001) The Abuja Declaration on HIV/AIDS, Tuberculosis and Other Related Infectious Diseases. Retrieved from http://www.un.org/ga/aids/pdf/abuja_declaration.pdf

AU - The African Union (2014a) AU in a nutshell. Retrieved from http://www.au.int/en/about/nutshell

AU - The African Union (2014b) Vision of the African Union. Retrieved from http://www.au.int/en/about/vision

Barth, F. (2002). Toward a Richer Description and Analysis of Cultural Phenomena. In R. Fox G., & B. King J (Eds.), Anthropology Beyond Culture (pp. 23-36). New York: Berg Publishers.

Binder, G. (1999): Cultural Relativism and Cultural Imperialism in Human Rights Law. 5 Buffalo Human Rights Law Rev. (pp. 211-221).

Boyd, L. (2013). The Problem With Freedom: Homosexuality and Human Rights in Uganda. Anthropological Quarterly. Vol. 86, No. 3, pp. 697-724. DOI:10.1353/anq.2013.0034

Butt, D (2013). Colonialism and Postcolonialism. Forthcoming in Hugh Lafolette (ed.) The International Encyclopedia of Ethics (Wiley-Blackwell).

Choe, Y. (2007 September 1). The Surprising History of Homosexuality and Homophobia. Retrieved from http://reflectionsasia.wordpress.com/2007/09/01/the-surprising-history-of-homosexuality-and-homophobia/

Cini, M.; Borragán, N. (2013) European Union Politics. 4th Edition. Oxford: Oxford University Press

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, No. 108 of 1996, Bill of Rights. Retrieved from http://www.gov.za/documents/constitution/1996/a108-96.pdf

Demont-Heinrich, C. (2011). Cultural Imperialism Versus Globalization of Culture: Riding the Structure-Agency Dialectic in Global Communication and Media Studies. Sociology Compass Vol 5 No. 8, pp. 666-678. DOI:10.1111/j.1751-9020.2011.00401.x

Dunch, R. (2002). Beyond Cultural Imperialism: Cultural Theory, Christian Missions, and Global Modernity. History and Theory. Vol 41, (pp. 301-325).

Divani, A. (2011, October 12). Is Homosexuality "Un-African"? Think Africa Press. Retrieved from http://thinkafricapress.com/gender/homosexuality-un-african-colonialism

Donnelly, J. (2011) Human Rights in Baylis, J., Smith, S., & Owens, P. (2011). The globalization of world politics. New York: Oxford University Press (pp. 496-508).

Donnelly, J. (2007) The Relative Universality of Human Rights. Human Rights Quarterly vol. 29 no. 2 (pp. 281-306). DOI:10.1353/hrq.2007.0016

Donnelly, J. (1984) Cultural Relativism and Universal Human Rights. Human Rights Quarterly. Vol. 6 no. 4 (pp. 400-419).

ECHR - The European Court on Human Rights (2003) L. and V. v. Austria (39392/98 and 39829/98, 9 January 2003) ECHR 2003-I.

Edgar, A. &Sedgwick, P. (2008) Cultural Theory: The Key Concepts. 2nd Edition. London and New York: Routledge.

Eitzen, D.S. & Zinn, M.B. Globalization: The Transformation of Social Worlds. 3rd Edition (pp 319-321). Belmont: Wadsworth.

Epprecht, M. (2012). Sexual Minorities, Human Rights and Public Health Strategies in Africa. Oxford University Press. (pp. 223-243).

European Convention on Human Rights (1950) Council of Europe. Adopted 4 November 1950. Entered into force 3 September 1953.

European Court of Human Rights (2002, 26 February) Fretté v. France (Application no. 36515/97).

European Court of Human Rights (2003, 9 January) L. and V. v. Austria (Application no. 39392/98 and 29829/98).

Evaristo, B. (2014 March 8). The Idea That African Homosexuality was a Colonial Import is a Myth. The Guardian. Retrieved from: http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/mar/08/african-homosexuality-colonial-import-myth

FRA (2010) European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights. Handbook on European non-discrimination Law. Luxembourg.

Freeman, M. (2011). Key concepts: Human rights. 2nd Edition. Cambridge: Polity Press.

Gary, J. & Rubin, N. S. (2012). Are LGBT human rights?/ Recent developments at the United Nations. American Psychological Association. Retrieved from https://www.apa.org/international/pi/2012/06/un-matters.aspx

Han, E. & O'Mahoney, J. (2014). British colonialism and the criminalization of homosexuality. Cambridge Review of International Affairs. DOI:10.1080/09557571.2013.867298

Hannerz, U. (1999). Reflections on Varieties of  Culturespeak. European Journal of Cultural Studies, Vol. 2 No. 3 (pp. 393-407).DOI: 10.1177/136754949900200306

Hendricks, J. (2000). Dependency Theory. In E.F. Borgatta & R.J.V. Montgomery (Eds) Encyclopedia of Sociology (second ed).

Heywood, A. (2011). Global Politics. Hampshire: Palgrave Macmillan.

Homosexuality (2011, February 11). Retrieved from http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/homosexuality/

Horvath, R. J. (1972). A Definition of Colonialism. Current Anthropology. Vol. 13, No. 1, pp. 45-57.

International Gay & Lesbian Human Rights Commission (2014 February 13) - Human Rights for Everyone. Everywhere. Nigeria Same-Sex Marriage (Prohibition) Act: Global Day of Action. Retrieved from https://iglhrc.org/content/nigeria-global-action

ILGA - International Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Trans and Intersex Association (2006 June 14). Arrests in Cameroon. Retrieved from http://ilga.org/ilga/en/article/833

ILGA - International Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Trans and Intersex Association (2013 May) State-sponsored Homophobia: a world survey of laws: Criminalization, protection and recognition of same-sex love (pp. 1-110).

ILGA - International Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Trans and Intersex Association (2014). Retrieved from www.ilga.org

Jacques, M. (2006) We Are Globalised, but Have No Real Intimacy with the Rest of the World. In Eitzen, D.S. & Zinn, M.B. Globalization: The Transformation of Social Worlds. 3rd Edition  (pp 319-321) Belmont: Wadsworth.

Johnson, P. (2013). Homosexuality and the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights: What can be Learned From the History of the European Convention on Human Rights? Journal of Law and Society. Vol. 40. No. 2 (pp.249-79).

Kalende, V. (2014 30 April) Africa: Homophobia is a legacy of colonialism. Guardian Africa Network. Retrieved from http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/apr/30/africa-homophobia-legacy-colonialism

Kettel, S. & Sutton, A. (2013). New Imperialism: Toward a Holistic Approach. International Studies Review. Vol. 15. (pp 243-258). DOI:10.1111/misr.12033

Khapoya, V. B. (2012). The African Experience. 4th Edition. (pp. 99-138). Toronto: Pearson.

Kielsgard, M. D. (2011) Universalism and Human Rights in the 21st Century. Asia Pacific Law Review Vol. 19 No 2. (pp. 155-176).

Kieh Jr, G. K. (1992). The Roots of Western Influence in Africa: An Analysis of the Conditioning Process. The Social Science Journal. Vol. 29. No. 1. (pp. 7-19). DOI: 10.1016/0362-3319(92)90013-8.

LeBaron, M. (2003). Culture and Conflict. Retrieved from http://www.beyondintractability.org/bi-essay/culture-conflict

Lembembe, E. O. (2012, May 8). What Traditional African Homosexuality Learned From the West. Retrieved from: http://76crimes.com/2012/05/08/traditional-african-homosexuality-has-learned-from-west/

Matshekga, J. N. (2003) The African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights and the Protection and Promotion of the Right to Equality and Non-Discrimination for Homosexuals: A Discussion. Fundamina vol 9 (pp 114-123).

Movius, L (2010 January) Cultural Globalisation and Challenges to Traditional Communication Theories. Journal of Media and Communication 2(1) (pp. 6-18).

Murden, S. (2011). Culture in World Affairs. In Baylis, J., Smith, S & Owens, P (Eds.), The Globalization of World Politics (414-427). New York: Oxford University Press.

Murray, R. & Viljoen, F. (2007) Towards Non-Discrimination on the Basis of Sexual Orientation: The Normative Basis and Procedural Possibilities before the African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights and the African Union. Human Rights Quarterly Vol. 29 No. 1 (pp 86-111). DOI: 10.1353/hrq.2007.0010

Murray, R (2013 July 26). United Nations Launches Free & Equal for LGBT People Around the World. Retrieved from https://www.glaad.org/blog/united-nations-launches-free-equal-lgbt-people-around-world

Murray, S.O. & Roscoe, W. (1998). Boy-Wives and Female Husbands: Studies of African Homosexualities. London: Macmillan.

Nagengast, C. (1997). Women, Minorities, and Indigenous Peoples: Universalism and Cultural Relativity. Journal of Anthropological Research vol. 53 no. 3 Universal Human Rights versus Cultural Relativity (pp. 349-369).

Okere, B. O. (1984) The Protection of Human Rights and the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights: A Comparative Analysis with the European and American Systems. Human Rights Quarterly. Vol. 6 no. 2 (pp. 141-159).

Penna, D. R. & Campbell, P. J. (1998) Human Rights and Culture: Beyond Universality and Relativism. Third World Quarterly Vol. 19 No. 1 (pp. 7-27).

Roach, C. (1997). Cultural Imperialism and Resistance in Media Theory and Literary Theory. Media, Culture & Society. Sage Publications. DOI:10.1177/016344397019001004

Sarikakis, K. (2005) Legitimating Domination: Notes on the Changing Faces of Cultural Imperialism in Hamm, B & Smandych, R (2005). Cultural Imperialism: Essays on the Political Economy of Cultural Domination. (Eds.). Ontario: Boradview Press Ltd.

Sarmela, M. (1977). What is Cultural Imperialism? In Carola Sandbacka (ed.), Cultural Imperialism and Cultural Identity (pp. 13-36). Transactions of the Finnish Anthropolological Society 2. Helsinki 1977 (in Finnish 1975).

Semplici, S. (2013). Balancing the principles: why the universality of human rights is not the Trojan horse of moral imperialism. Med Health Care and Philos Vol. 16 No. 4 (pp. 653-661). DOI:10.1007/s11019-013-9495-z

Smith, D. (2014, February 23). Why Africa is the most homophobic continent. The Guardian/The Observer. Retrieved from http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/feb/23/africa-homophobia-uganda-anti-gay-law

Somerville, S. (1994). Scientific Racism and the Emergence of the Homosexual Body. Journal of the History of Sexuality. Vol. 5 No. 2. (pp. 243-266). University of Texas Press.

Sparks, C. (2012). Media and Cultural Imperialism Reconsidered. Chinese Journal of Communication. Vol. 5 No. 3, (pp. 281-299). DOI: 10.1080/17544750.2012.701417

Stout, J. R. (N.Y). Sin and Sexuality: Psychobiology and the Development of Homosexuality. Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought. (pp. 29-41).

Thoreson, R. R. (2014). Troubling the Waters of a 'Wave of Homophobia': Political Economies of Anti-queer Animus in sub-Saharan Africa. Sexualities. Vol. 17(1/2) (pp. 23-42). DOI: 10.1177/1363460713511098.

Taylor, P. & Curtis, D. (2011). The United Nations in Baylis, J., Smith S. & Owens, P. The Globalization of World Politics: an Introduction to International Relations. Oxford: Oxford University Press (pp. 312-324).

Traoré, R. L. (2004). Colonialism Continued: African Students in an Urban High School in America. Journal of Black Studies. Vol. 34. No. 3. (pp. 348-369). DOI: 10.1177/0021934703258986

UDHR - United Nations (1948). Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Adopted by the United Nations. Entered into force on December 10 1948.

UNFE - United Nations Free & Equal (2014a). Retrieved from  https://www.unfe.org/?type=human%20rights&locale=en

UNFE - United Nations Free & Equal (2014b) The History of LGBT Rights at the UN [Motion picture].  Retrieved from https://www.unfe.org/en/actions/human-rights-day

United Nations (2014a). At UN Meeting, Countries Commit to Protect Gay Rights, Combat Discrimination. Retrieved from http://www.un.org/apps/news/story.asp?NewsID=46036&Cr=lesbian&Cr1#.U1D-j1efXbM

United Nations Human Rights (2012a). Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights. Born Free and Equal. Retrieved from http://www.ohchr.org/EN/NewsEvents/Pages/BornFreeAndEqual.aspx

United Nations Human Rights (2012b). Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights. Born Free and Equal - Sexual Orientations and Gender Identity in International Human Rights Law. Retrieved from http://www.ohchr.org/Documents/Publications/BornFreeAndEqualLowRes.pdf

United Nations (2010). Universal Decriminalization of Homosexuality a Human Rights Imperative. United Nations News Centre. Retrieved from http://www.un.org/apps/news/story.asp?NewsID=37026#.U3DGuF5MkwE

United Nations (2013). UN Unveils 'Free & Equal' Campaign to Promote Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender Rights. United Nations News Centre. Retrieved from http://www.un.org/apps/news/story.asp?NewsID=45503&Cr=lesbian&Cr1#.U3NwGFefXbM

U.S (2014). US Department of State Office of the Historian. Decolonization of Asia and Africa, 1945-1960. Retrieved from http://history.state.gov/milestones/1945-1952/asia-and-africa

Van Zyl, M. (2011). Are Same-Sex Marriages UnAfrican? Same-Sex Relationships and Belonging in Post-Apartheid South Africa. Journal of Social Issues. Vol. 67 No. 2 (pp 335-357). DOI:10.1111/j.1540-4560.2011.01701.x

WHO - World Health Organization (2011). Global HIV/AIDS Response: Epidemic update and health sector progress towards Universal Access (pp. 1-219).

WHO - World Health Organization (2013). HIV Department: Core epidemiological slides. HIV/AIDS estimates November 2013 (pp. 1-12).

Ziltener, P. & Künzler, D. (2013). Impacts of Colonialism - A Research Survey. American Sociological Association. Vol. 19. No. 2. (pp. 290-311).






Share with your friends:
1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   10




The database is protected by copyright ©essaydocs.org 2020
send message

    Main page