Kicking out of disads worksheet name



Download 9 Kb.
Date conversion21.03.2016
Size9 Kb.


KICKING OUT OF DISADS WORKSHEET NAME: ________________

Kicking out of Disads is a necessary skill for the negatives. As the year progresses, the strategy of going for everything in the 2NR or even in the block ("the farm") will be less and less effective. The best varsity teams only go for one Disad, however this does not stop them from running 2-4 Disads in the 1NC. In order to insure that the Affirmative does not extend its turns, both negative speakers must learn how to concede the Disads. This applies to every disad you drop, even the ones which you do not think the Aff ran turns on (remember that even if answers are initially not labeled turns, they have a nasty habit of turning into turns in the 1AR). In order to kick out of a DA you should extend all non-turn answers and explain why the DA no longer exists if you concede the answers. Be careful, however, certain non-turn answers such as non-unique cannot be safely conceded as they feed the link turns.


Assume you run politics, with the following in the 1NC, under which circumstances can you kick the DA and which answers could you concede. For each, write out what you would say in block to kick out of the DA.
1NC Shell

A. ANWR will not pass now

B. Popular presidents get their agenda, aff plan is popular

C. ANWR drilling kills species, biodiversity


SCENARIO A

1) No link, popularity not key to agenda

2) No impact, drilling in ANWR will not kill species

3) Case Outweighs

4) no threshold to killing ANWR species
Can you kick the DA? _____; which answers would you concede?:_______________

Write out what you would say in the block on a separate piece of paper


Scenario B

1) non-unique ANWR will pass now

2) winners lose, the plan kills Bush's political capital

3) MPAs are unpopular

4) no internal link, ANWR drilling won't kill species
Can you kick the DA? _____; which answers would you concede?:_______________

Write out what you would say in the block on a separate piece of paper


Scenario C

1) non-unique ANWR will pass now

2) no link, popularity doesn't determine the agenda

3) Bush loses political capital, liberal policies alienate his base

4) Bush loses political capital, winners lose
Can you kick the DA? _____; which answers would you concede?:_______________

Write out what you would say in the block on a separate piece of paper

Scenario D

1) no impact, species will migrate

2) ANWR key to solve oil dependency

3) oil key to US economy

4) ANWR drilling prevents drilling in other areas which kills species
Can you kick the DA? _____; which answers would you concede?:_______________

Write out what you would say in the block on a separate piece of paper


Scenario E

1) Non-unique, other things kill species

2) Bush loses political capital, he flip flops if he passes the aff.

3) Bush loses political capital, plan is unpopular

4) Bush loses political capital, he alienates his base
Can you kick the DA? _____; which answers would you concede?:_______________

Write out what you would say in the block on a separate piece of paper


Scenario F

1) No link, popularity does not determine agenda

2) Bush loses political capital, he flip flops if he passes the aff.

3) Bush loses political capital, winners lose

4) Case outweighs the impact
Can you kick the DA? _____; which answers would you concede?:_______________

Write out what you would say in the block on a separate piece of paper


Scenario G

1) No link, popularity does not determine agenda

2) Bush loses political capital, he flip flops if he passes the aff.

3) ANWR key to solve oil dependency

4) oil key to US economy
Can you kick the DA? _____; which answers would you concede?:_______________

Write out what you would say in the block on a separate piece of paper





The database is protected by copyright ©essaydocs.org 2016
send message

    Main page