Identity in northern ireland: what is it? Community Dialogue Worksheet Series: Number One The Community Dialogue Worksheet Series



Download 16.75 Kb.
Date conversion05.05.2016
Size16.75 Kb.
IDENTITY IN NORTHERN IRELAND: WHAT IS IT?

Community Dialogue Worksheet Series: Number One

The Community Dialogue Worksheet Series

Our Worksheets are dialogue aids providing accessible summaries of complex issues.

Introduction: Identity is how you see yourself and how others see you. This worksheet explores some general aspects of identity in NI.
Components: Identity is a combination of different components that play varying roles in who we are, how we are treated and how we feel.
Some Examples Of Components That Make Up Identity

Sex- Male / Female Language- Irish / English

Religion- Christian / Muslim Politics- Nationalist / Unionist

Class- Working / Middle Ethnicity- Traveller / Chinese



Age- Teenager / Elderly Sexuality- Heterosexual / Gay



Questions: Can you list all the components of your identity? What do they say about who you are? How do they affect the way you are treated and how you feel?
Relationships: Identity involves relationships with others. More important relationships e.g. family are central to our identity; less important ones e.g. sport are peripheral.
Questions: Which aspects of your identity are most important to you? Why?
We Are Who We’re Born: The accident of birth is very influential in determining our identity e.g. if you are born into a Jewish family it is likely that you will always feel Jewish. Where we live and go to school further reinforce this.
Question: How was your identity influenced by birth?
Resources: Money and education can free people from aspects of identity they were born with by giving them choices they might not otherwise have.
Question: What role did money and education play in making you who you are?
Who We Aren’t: Identity defines who we aren’t and whom we are opposed to. Most of us grew up in NI identifying strongly with one community e.g. Catholic, Protestant or Chinese. We do not tend to mix with those outside our community, viewing them with suspicion and applying negative stereotypes to them.
Questions: Do aspects of your identity define whom you are against? How?


Being Boxed: Society may see us differently to how we see ourselves leaving us feeling boxed in e.g. a man with Black ancestry born, educated and living in NI may regard himself as British and / or Irish but because of his skin colour some people may always view him as a Black.
Questions: In what ways have you been boxed in? How did it feel?
Symbolism: People display identity through murals (Loyalist, Republican), parades (Orange Order, Gay Pride) and sport (Celtic, Rangers). This is interpreted differently by different groups e.g. many Protestants see Orange parades as celebrating culture and religion, but many Catholics see them as intimidating displays of triumphalism.
Questions: How do you display your identity? Why? What do others read into it?
Time: Identity changes through time. Many Catholics felt they were oppressed in NI but gradual political change brought more equality resulting in a growing sense of freedom and confidence. The Anglo-Irish Agreement left many Protestants feeling that the government, instead of protecting their British identity, threatened it. Consequently some began focusing their identity on a narrower Ulster Scottish aspect of Britishness.
Questions: Has your identity changed through time? How?
Threat: When identity is threatened it becomes more important e.g. tension around Orange parades can heighten awareness of political, cultural and religious identity.
Questions: How has your identity been threatened? How did this affect you?
Conflict: Tension between identities often leads to conflict; NI has a long history of conflict between political (Nationalist, Unionist) and religious (Catholic, Protestant) identities.
Questions: Have you been involved in conflict because of your identity? Why?
Diversity: NI is becoming more diverse. Ethnic and other identity groups are increasing and there has been a consequent rise in racist and other (e.g. homophobic) violence.
Some Of NI’s Diverse Identity Groups


Travellers, Italians, Indians, Protestants, Lithuanians, Algerians, Jews, Angolans, Brazilians,

Muslims, Catholics, Kenyans, Libyans, South Africans, Chinese, Sikhs, Afghans,

Sudanese, Hindus, Nigerians, Albanians, Romanians, Hare Krishnan’s,

Lesbians, Macedonians, Croatians, Humanists, Moldavians,

Serbians, Gays, Slovakians,

Portuguese.





Question: Should we encourage people to respect and value diversity in NI or would it be better if everyone were of the same race, ethnicity, religion, culture, sexual orientation and political persuasion?


This worksheet was produced in August 2004 and revised in March 2013

Community Dialogue promotes dialogue on the critical issues affecting our future.

To find out more contact:
Community Dialogue, NCM House, 218 Antrim Road, Belfast BT15 1GY

t: 028 90 351 450 e:admin@communitydialogue.org w: www.communitydialogue.org


The database is protected by copyright ©essaydocs.org 2016
send message

    Main page