2005, Jan. 20
Кremenyuk, Victor. (2006) Rossiya vne mirovogo soobschestva (Russia is outside the world community). Mezhdunarodnyye protsessy 4, 3 2007, June 18.
Kulagin, Vladimir М. (2002) “Mir v XXI veke: mnogopolyusnyi balans sil ili global’nyi Pax Democratica? (The world in the 21st century: a multipolar balance of power or a global Pax Democratica?)” In Vneshnyaya politika i bezopasnost’ sovremennoi Rossiyi, 1991-2002. vol. 1, edited by T. Shakleyina, pp. 145-161. Moscow: ROSSPEN.
Kulagin, Vladimir М. (2004) Rezhimnyi faktor vo vneshnei politike postsovetskikh gosudarstv (The regime factor in foreign policy of the post-Soviet states). Polis, No. 1: 115-124.
Kulagin, Vladimir (2007) Mezhdunarodnaya bezopasnost’ (International security). Moskva: Aspekt-press.
Kulagin, Vladimir (2008) Netlennost’ avtoritarnosti? (The eternal authoritarianism?) Mezhdunarodnyye protsessy 6, 1, January-April
Lavrov, Sergei (2009) Interview of Russian Minister of Foreign Affairs with the BBC Russian Service, April 23.
Larsson, Robert L. (2006) Russia’s Energy Policy: Security Dimensions and Russia’s Reliability as an Energy Supplier. Stockholm: Swedish Defense Research Agency.
Lebedeva, Marina M. (2004) Mirovaya politika (World politics). Mezhdunarodnyye protsessy 2
Lebedeva, Marina (2008). Politicheskaya sistema mira: proyavleniya “vnesistemnosti” (The political system of the world: expressions of non-systemic qualities). In “Privatizatsiya” mirovoi politiki: lokal’nyye deystviya – global’nyye rezul’taty, edited by Marina Lebedeva. Мoskva: MGIMO.
Lenin, V. (1976 ) Imperialism. In: Selected Works. Vol. 1. Moscow: Progress.
Leontyev, Konstantin. (2005 ). Vizantizm i slavyanstvo. (Bysantium and Slavs) Moscow: Dar’.
Linklater, Andrew. (1998) The Transformation of Political Community. Oxford: Polity Press.
Маtveychev, Oleg (2007) Suverenitet dukha (the spiritual sovereignty). Мoskva: Pokoleniye.
Mandelbaum, Michael (2005) The Ideas That Conquered the World. New York: Public Affairs.
Mansfield, Edward D. and Helen V. Milner, eds. 1997. The Political Economy of Regionalism. NY: Columbia University Press.
Mansfield, Edward D. and Jack Snyder. 2007. Electing to Fight: Why Emerging Democracies Go to War. Cambridge: The MIT Press.
Medvedev, Dmitri (2006) Dlya protsvetaniya vsekh nado uchityvat’ interesy kazhdogo (For everyone’s prosperity, one has to consider everyone’s interests). Ekspert, # 28 (522), July 24
Medvedev, Dmitry (2008) Speech at the 12th Petersburg International Economic Forum. Saint Petersburg, June 7, 2008
Medvedev, Dmitri (2009) Poslaniye Prezidenta Federal’nomu Sobraniyu Rossiyskoy Federatsiyi (Address to Federation Counsil of the Russian Federation). Kremlin.ru, November 12.
Medvedev, Dmitri (2010) Speech at meeting with Russian ambassadors and permanent representatives in international organisations, Kremlin.ru, July 12.
Murphy, Craig N. (2001) Political Consequences of the New Inequality. International Studies Quarterly 45, 3, September.
Nartov, Nikolai A. (1999) Geopolitika. Moskva: Iuniti.
Ohmae, Kenichi (1991) The Borderless World: Power and Strategy in the Interlinked Economy. New York: Harper-Perennial.
Oren, Ido. (2002) Our Enemy and US: America’s Rivalries and the Making of Political Science. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Panarin, Aleksandr (1999). Rossiya v tsiklah mirovoi istoriyi (Russia in the cycles of world history). Moskva: MGU.
Panarin, A. (2002) Pravoslavnaya tsivilizatsiya v sovremennom mire (The Orthodox civilization in the contemporary world). Moskva: Algoritm.
Pavlovski, G. (2004) Rossiya vsye yeschye ischet svoyi rol’ v mire (Russians are still search for their place in the world). Nezavisimaya gazeta, May 31.
Pantin, Vladimir I. and Vladimir V. Lapkin (2006) Filosofiya istoricheskogo prognozirovaniya: Ritmy i perspektivy mirovogo razvitiya v pervoi polovine XXI veka (The philosophy of historical forcasting). Dubna: Feniks.
Pastukhov, Viktor. (2000) Natsional’nyi i gosudarstvennyi interes Rossiyi (the national and state interest of Russia). Polis 1.
Putin, Vladimir (2002) Poslaniye Prezidenta Federal’nomu Sobraniyu Rossiyskoy Federatsii (Address to Federation Counsil of the Russian Federation). Mezhdunarodnaya zhizn’, 5.
Putin, Vladimir. (2005) Poslaniye Prezidenta Federal’nomu Sobraniyu Rossiyskoy Federatsiyi (Address to Federation Counsil of the Russian Federation). March
RFE/RL (March 14, 2008) Putin Wants “Deeper Friendship” with Islamic World.
RFE/RL (January 11, 2008) Minister Hails Ties to Muslim World.
RosBusinessConsulting (2007) Russians like order and justice. RosBusinessConsulting, March 28.
Russkaya doktrina (2007) Russkaya doktrina (The Russian doctrine). Moskva: Yauza.
Sergeyev, Viktor. (2001) Ekonomicheskiye tsentry sily na poroge XXI veka (Economic centers of power in the beginning of the 21st century). In: Mir Rossiyi na poroge XXI veka, edited by A. V. Torkunov, 224-231. Moscow: ROSSPEN.
Shakhnazarov, Georgi (2000) Otkroveniya i zabluzhdeniya teoriyi tsivilizatsi (Insights and errors of civilizational theory). Moskva: Sovremennyi gumanitarnyi universitet.
Shakleyina, Tatyana A., ed. (2002) Vneshnyaya politika i bezopasnost’ sovremennoi Rossiyi, 1991-2002 (the foreign and security policy of contemporary Russia, 1991-2002) . Vol. 4. Moscow: ROSSPEN.
Shakleyina, Tatyana A. (2003) Rossiya i SShA v novom mirovom poryadke (Russia and the USA in the new world order). Moskva: Institute SSha i Kanady.
Shakleyina, Tatyana and Aleksei Bogaturov (2004) Ilyin, Mikhail V. (2004) The Russian Realist school of international relations. Communist and Post-Communist Studies, Vol. 37, No. 1, March.
Shani, Giorgio (2008) Towards a Post-Western IR: The Umma, Khalsa Panth and Critical International Theory. International Studies Review, forthcoming.
Sheinis, Viktor L. (2003) Natsional’nyeye interesy i vneshnyaya politika Rossiyi (National interests and foreign policy of Russia). Mirovaya ekonomika i mezhdunarodnyye otnosheniya 4:33-46.
Shevtsova, Lilia. (2001) Vystupleniye (Presentation). In: Rossiya i Zapad. Foundation “Liberal’naya missiya”, January 28 2003, March 3.
Shevtsova, Lilia. (2003) Putin’s Russia. Washington, DC: Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.
Shishkov, Yuri. (2003) Globalizatsiya – vrag ili soyuznik razvivayuschikhsya stran (Globalization – a friend or foe of the developing countries). Mirovaya ekonomika i mezhdunarodnyye otnosheniya 1:3-14.
Shlapentokh, Dmitri (2007) Dugin Eurasianism: a window on the minds of the Russian elite or an intellectual ploy? Studies in East European Thought 59, 3, September.
Solovyev, Eduard G. (2008) Russian Geopolitics in the Context of Globalization. In: Russia and Globalization: Identity, Security and Society in an Era of Change, edited by Douglas W. Blum. Washington, DC: Woodrow Wilson Center Press / Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press.
Solzenitsyn, Aleksandr (1974) Iz-pod glyb (From under the rubbles). Paris: Imca-Press.
Stallings, Barbara, ed. 1995. Global Change, Regional Response : the New International Context of Development. Cambridge, New York: Cambridge University Press.
Stulberg, Adam N. (2007) Well-Oiled Diplomacy: Strategic Manipulation and Russia’s Energy Statecraft in Eurasia. New York: CUNY Press.
Surkov, Vladislav (2006) Suverenitet – eto politicheski sinonim konkurentnosposobnosti (Sovereignty is a political synonim of competitiveness). Moscow News, March 3
Tickner, J. Ann. (2001) Gendering World Politics. New York: Columbia University Press.
Tolstykh, Valentin (2003) Global’nyye vyzovy i poiski otveta (Global challenges and search for a response)). In: Grani globalizatsiyi, edited by Mikhail Gorbachev. Moskva: Al’pina.
Torkunov, Anatoli. 2006. Rossiyskaya model’ demokratiyi i sovremennoye global’noye upravleniye (The Russian model of democracy and contemporary global governance). Mezhdunarodnyye Protsessy 4, 1 2007, June 17.
Tretyakov, Vitali (2005) Suverennaya demokratiya. O politicheskoi filosofiyi Vladimira Putina (the sovereign democracy: on Putin’s political philosophy). Rossiyskaya gazeta, April 28
Trenin, Dmitri. (2001) The End of Eurasia: Russia on the Border Between Geopolitics and Globalization. Moscow: Carnegie Moscow Center.
Trenin, Dmitri. (2006) Integratsiya i identichnost: Rossiya kak 'novyi Zapad' (Integration and Identity: Russia as a “new West”). Moscow: Carnegie Moscow Center.
Tsipko, Aleksandr (2006) Obratno puti net (there is no way back). Literaturnaya Gazeta, No. 19, May.
Tsygankov, Andrei P. (2005) The Return to Eurasia: Russia’s Identity and Geoeconomic Choices in the Post-Soviet World. In Economic Nationalism in a Globalizing World, edited by Eric Helleiner and Andreas Pickel. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 2005.
Tsygankov, Andrei P. (2007) Finding a Civilizational Idea: ‘West’, ‘Eurasia’ and ‘Euro-East’ in Russia’s Foreign Policy. Geopolitics 12, 3.
Tsygankov, Andrei P. (2008) Self and Other in International Relations Theory: Learning from Russian Civilizational Debates. International Studies Review 10, 4.
Tsygankov, Andrei P. (2011) Preserving Influence in a Changing World: Russia’s Grand Strategy. Problems of Post-Communism 58, 1, March-April.
Tsygankov, Andrei P. and Pavel A. Tsygankov (2007) Sociology of Dependence in International Relations Theory: A Case of Russian Liberal IR. International Political Sociology 1, 4, November.
Tsygankov, Andrei P. and Pavel A. Tsygankov (2010) National Ideology and IR Theory: Three Incarnations of the “Russian Idea.” European Journal of International Relations 16, 4, December.
Utkin, Anatoli (2006) Novyi mirovoi poryadok (The new world order). Moskva: Algoritm.
Vekhi: Sbornik statei (Landmarks: Essays). (1991 ) Moskva: Molodaya gvardiya.
Volodin, Andrei G. and Georgi K. Shirokov. (2002) Globalizatsiya: nachala, tendentsiyi, perspektivy (Globalization: the nature, trends, and prospects). Moscow: Nauka.
Volodin, Andrei. (2006) Neliberal’nyye demokratiyi i politicheskaya effektivnost’ (Neoliberal democracies and political effectiveness). Mezhdunarodnyye Protsessy. Vol. 4, No. 1, January-April. 2007, June 20.
Voytolovski, Fedor (2007) Ideologicheskaya refleksiya mirovoi politiki (the ideological reflection of the world politics). Mezhdunarodnyye protsessy 5, 3, September-December
Waever, Ole (1998) The sociology of a not so international discipline: American and European developments in international relations. International Organization 52.
Yasin, Yevgeni. (2001) Vystupleniye (Presentation). In: Rossiya v poiskakh strategicheskoi pozitsiyi. Foundation “Liberal’naya missiya”, January 14 2003, March 3.
Yasin, Yevgeni. (2004) Modernizatsiya ekonomiki i sistema tsennostei (Economic modernization and the values’ system). Moscow: Vysshaya shkoly ekonomiki.
Zyuganov, Gennadi. (1999) Geografiya pobedy (The geography of victory). Moskva: an unknown publisher.
Zyuganov, Gennadi. (2002) Globalizatsiya i sud’ba chelovechestva (Globalization and future of humanity). Moskva: Molodaya gvardiya.
1 Some of themes of this essay are explored in greater details in Tsygankov 2005; Tsygankov and Tsygankov 2007, 2010.
2 The passage is from Putin’s PhD thesis “Meneral Raw Materials in the Strategy for Development of the Russian Economy” defended in 1999 (As cited in Larsson 2006, 58). For various overviews of Russia’s energy thinking and policy, see Hill 2004; Balzer 2006; Larsson 2006; Stulberg 2007.
3 Not all in the Kremlin share the notion of sovereign democracy. For alternative perspective from the current President of Russia, see Medvedev 2006.
For development of this argument, see Tsygankov and Tsygankov 2010. For a recent theoretical discussion of ideology
, see Gerring 1997 and Freeden 2006.
5 See Konyshev 2004, 2005 for a detailed analysis of the U.S. neorealist scholarship and its influence on Russian academia.
6 As E. H. Carr observed in 1977, the “study of international relations in English-speaking countries is simply a study of the best way to run the world from positions of strength. The study of international relations in African and Asian universities, if it even got going, would be a study of the exploitation of the weaker by the stronger” (Quoted in Barkawi and Laffey 2006, 349).
For instance, Dmitri Trenin (2006), while granting Russia a right to pursue a distinct path, assumes that the country needs to “become” a part of Europe and the “new” West. Russia, he says, has been historically European
, yet it often “fell out of” Europe (2006, 63, 167) as a result of failed reform efforts. If this is the case, then what Russia really needs is to “return” to Europe, rather than preserve its identity and distinctiveness.
8 The sociology of knowledge tradition has drawn attention to the fact that scholarship is grounded in certain social conditions and may reflect ideological and cultural premises. For contemporary IR scholarship focusing on social foundations of knowledge, see especially, Hoffmann 1977; Waever 1998; Crawford and Jarvis 2001.
10 For a sample of representative work on global democratization, see Davydov 1999; Kulagin 2002, 2003, 2008.
11 Outside the democratic peace scholars, such reflections do exist. See, for example, Kapustin 2001; Torkunov 2006; Volodin 2006.
Ido Oren (2002) showed, for example, that definition of democracy within the United States has changed dramatically at least twice over the twentieth century – from a good governance under Woodrow Wilson to fighting poverty under the great depression and to elections and pluralistic institutions in the 1960s. On contested meaning of democracy in the United States
, see also Foner, 1998.
13 On the North-South division in viewing democratic peace, see Tickner 2001, 103.
14 Such was the position of Marina Lebedeva (2004), who initiated the discussion. Lebedeva was then engaged by several other participants, whose presentations have been published by the journal. The materials of the discussion can be found at
16 On Eurasianism and its influence in the contemporary Russia, see Bassin and Aksenov 2006; Shlapentokh 2007; Solovyev 2008.